Muscle, Breast and Other Biopsies Often Need a Second Opinion


Biopsies may need to be reviewed by a second physician, particularly if the diagnosis is unclear or if the findings do not go along with the clinical picture. It always troubles me to know how people given a serious diagnosis generally take the diagnosis at face value and don't get a second opinion.

Of particular concern are patients who have a muscle, breast or other biopsy done in a small private hospital and assume the diagnosis is correct.

Good pathologists know their limitations and often send biopsies out for a second opinion. However, even so-called  experts make mistakes. Sometimes egos are involved and the doctors don't want to admit they could ever be wrong. I remember one well known neuromuscular specialist who would not let me see the slides for a child I was to see from out of town. Fortunately, the father was a lawyer and insisted I see the slides. When I received them and was able to spend time looking at the muscle biopsy, I realized why the doctor didn't want me to see the slides. They were so badly processed they were unreadable. I never understood why he didn't have the technician re-do the slides because usually extra tissue is kept frozen so slides can be re-done.

I frequently received muscle biopsies from even big university medical schools that were so badly processed  there was just no way a diagnosis could be made. I would try to get the frozen block, so the biopsy slides could be re-done, but if that was not possible we did a repeat muscle biopsy using a local anesthetic. That is the way a muscle biopsy should be done to avoid the risk of Malignant Hyperthermia.  With a general anesthetic, a serious problem and even death can occur when a muscle biopsy is done if certain anesthetics are used when a patient has a particular muscle problem such as Central Core disease. So a second opinion may be life saving.

Image copyright: bradhoc/flickr/CC BY

Article last time updated on 02.11.2016.

1 rating(s) (5 ø)
Users must be logged in to comment Login
Click here and become a medical blogger!
t always hurts me to have a parent tell me that a son with Duchenne muscular dystrophy needed a wheelchair as early more...
I had a recent frantic call from a grandmother saying her three-year-old granddaughter, who lived in another state, more...
I frequently tell parents and friends that the Internet has a great deal of good information, but also considerable more...


PR-blogs on DocCheck are sponsored blogs which are published on DocCheck by commercial providers additionally to regular userblogs. They may contain promotional statements. DocCheck is not responsible for this content.

Copyright © 2018 DocCheck Medical Services GmbH
Follow DocCheck: